Field NotesComparisonsNo. 14

PAR meter vs. lux meter for plants: how to choose a PPFD meter

A lux meter tells you how bright a spot looks to you. A PAR meter counts the photons a plant can use. Here is when each one is enough, and which specs matter.

Hands hold a light meter with a separate sensor over seedlings under a pink grow light

The short answer A lux meter is enough for comparing spots under the same light, such as daylight from one window, and for checking houseplants against foot-candle charts. For grow lights, especially LEDs, or for working out daily light integral (DLI), use a PAR meter, which reads PPFD with a quantum sensor. Look for LED spectral error data, a stated cosine response, and calibration traceable to a national standard such as NIST.

Either meter beats your eyes, which greenhouse research guidelines in Plant Methods call “an inaccurate sensing device for quantifying light.” What each one counts decides whether its number means anything under your light.

For how much light plants need, see how much light does a houseplant need.

What each meter measures

A lux meter measures light weighted by how bright it looks to a person. Virginia Tech’s extension guide says the foot-candle “relied on human vision rather than plant growth,” and the lumen “is based on human vision and does not always translate well to plant growth.” It advises against lux, foot-candles and lumens as units for plant light.

A PAR meter (also called a PPFD meter or quantum meter) uses a quantum sensor to read photosynthetic photon flux density (PPFD) in µmol/m²/s. Apogee Instruments defines PPFD as the sum of photons from 400 to 700 nm, “equally weighting all photons” in that band.

One converts to the other only for a known light source. Virginia Tech’s full-sun example uses 5.01 foot-candles per µmol/m²/s, so 500 foot-candles of sunlight is about 100 µmol/m²/s. Under another lamp the factor changes, which is why the PPFD, lux and DLI calculator asks which light a reading was taken under and has no built-in LED factor.

When a lux meter is good enough

A lux meter works when the light source stays the same:

  • Comparing spots lit by the same daylight. One source means one conversion factor, so a spot reading half the lux of another gets about half the photons.
  • Checking houseplants against foot-candle charts. Many houseplant ranges, including the extension figures in the light guide, are written in foot-candles.

Reach for a PAR meter when:

  • Plants grow under LEDs or any lamp without a published conversion factor. Apogee’s spectral test list includes LEDs from a 448 nm blue to a 667 nm red, plus whites; no single lux factor covers them all.
  • Light is mixed, such as a window plus a grow light.
  • You want DLI, the day’s total in mol/m²/day.

Phone apps estimate light with the phone’s internal photodiode. Virginia Tech says an inexpensive app could give homeowners useful information; the light guide shows how far off one can be in dim light.

On price, Virginia Tech puts standalone quantum sensors at less than $100 to over $1,000, and spectroradiometers at $1,000 to over $2,500.

Spectral response: the spec that decides accuracy under LEDs

An ideal quantum sensor responds equally to every photon from 400 to 700 nm and ignores everything else. Real filters and detectors only approximate that flat response, and the error depends on how much of a lamp’s output falls where the real curve strays from flat. Sunlight is broad and forgiving. Narrow-band LEDs find the gaps.

Apogee is used as the example here because its manual publishes errors by light source, the kind of table worth looking for from any maker. It compares its full-spectrum SQ-500 with its older SQ-100 series, with errors calculated relative to clear-sky sunlight:

  • Cool white LED: SQ-100 off by 3.3%, SQ-500 by 0.5%
  • Warm white LED: 8.9% and 0.2%
  • Red LED, 667 nm peak: 62.1% and 2.8%
  • 80% red, 20% blue LED mix: 72.8% and 3.9%

Across all 16 sources listed, the SQ-500 stays within 3.9% by Apogee’s own figures.

A peer-reviewed 1993 HortScience study checked quantum sensors against a spectroradiometer under seven sources. Standard PAR sensors read within 7% of it for every source except red LEDs, where they, and a second sensor type tested, were off by more than 18%. The sensors were “most accurate for broad-band sources and least accurate for narrow-band sources.”

A 2018 conference study by Apogee scientists tested seven sensors and meters. The SQ-500, both LI-COR models tested and one other sensor had spectral and directional errors under 5%. Two others, including the SQ-100, use detectors “not sensitive to photons with wavelengths greater than about 660 nm,” and the authors advise caution with them under deep-red LEDs.

Ask for a spectral response curve plotted against the ideal, or an error table that includes a light like yours. If your meter has a light-source setting, that is a correction factor, so match it to your lamp. For research under LEDs, the Plant Methods guidelines recommend a spectroradiometer.

Cosine response: light from the side counts too

Light slants through windows and comes from several fixtures. Directional (cosine) response is a sensor’s error at a given angle of incidence, and it grows as light comes in lower. Apogee rates the SQ-500 at ±2% at 45° from vertical and ±5% at 75°. LI-COR says the LI-190R is “cosine corrected up to 82° angle of incidence.”

In the 2018 study, one of the meters tested showed “directional errors of up to 20% in the diffuse light that is characteristic of growth chambers,” and more in low-angle light. If a spec sheet doesn’t state cosine response, you can’t know how the meter handles side light.

Calibration, traceability and drift

Calibration ties a sensor’s output to a known amount of light; traceability means that chain leads back to a national standard. LI-COR states the LI-190R’s calibration as ±5%, traceable to the U.S. National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). Apogee calibrates each SQ-500 against the mean of four transfer-standard sensors under a reference lamp, and recalibrates those with a NIST-traceable quartz halogen lamp, for a stated uncertainty of ±5%.

The Plant Methods guidelines list ±10% as the accuracy of reading for a quantum sensor. Repeatability is far tighter (under 0.5% for the SQ-500), which is why plant sensors compared makes the case for logging one sensor over time.

Both makers state drift under 2% a year. Apogee generally recommends recalibration every two years. The guidelines list yearly calibration against a reference sensor or standard lamp, plus calibration before and after experiments, and say to follow the maker’s advice on factory recalibration. Keep the diffuser clean in between: Apogee suggests water or window cleaner on a soft cloth, vinegar for salt deposits, and nothing abrasive.

Sensor size and averaging

A quantum sensor is small (the SQ-500 is 24 mm across, the LI-190R 2.36 cm), so each reading covers one spot. Under grow lights that matters, because, per Plant Methods, “the spatial uniformity of radiation emanating from supplementary lighting systems is less than that of solar radiation.” One reading may not represent the whole shelf.

Either take readings in a grid and average them, or use a line quantum sensor, which averages along its length. LI-COR’s LI-191R senses along a strip 1 m long and 12.7 mm wide. The trade-off is looser accuracy: ±10% calibration, and sensitivity that varies up to ±7% along the strip.

How to take a good reading

  • Height. Measure at the top of the canopy, and note that height against a fixed point, such as the bottom of the light fixture (as Plant Methods suggests).
  • Angle. Hold the sensor level. Apogee: “To accurately measure PPFD incident on a horizontal surface, the sensor must be level.”
  • Shade. Keep your hand, head and leaves off the sensor; the guidelines also warn of “noise from reflective surfaces.”
  • Several spots. Take more than one reading and note the average and the spread, as the guidelines ask. Under a grow light, include the center, edges and corners.
  • Time of day. Daylight changes hourly and with the weather, so one reading is a snapshot. The guidelines call for PAR measurements “preferably continuous but at least hourly.”
  • Logging. For daylight DLI, log continuously and total each day, as the guidelines recommend. Apogee rates the SQ-500’s daily-total uncertainty under 5%.

For a grow light with steady output, Virginia Tech’s formula turns the average reading into a daily total:

DLI = PPFD × hours × 0.0036

DLI is in mol/m²/day, PPFD is the average canopy reading in µmol/m²/s, hours is how long the light runs each day, and 0.0036 converts units (3,600 seconds per hour, divided by 1,000,000 µmol per mol).

Example: 250 µmol/m²/s for 14 hours gives 250 × 14 × 0.0036 = 12.6 mol/m²/day. Calibration uncertainty alone (±5%) puts the true value at roughly 12.0 to 13.2. With the SQ-100’s 72.8% error under an 80/20 red and blue LED, the figure tells you little.

Spec checklist for a PAR meter

Spec What to look for Example from a maker’s spec sheet
Spectral response Near-flat 400 to 700 nm; an error table with LEDs SQ-500: within 3.9% across 16 sources
Cosine response Error stated for low-angle light SQ-500: ±2% at 45°, ±5% at 75°; LI-190R: corrected to 82°
Calibration Stated uncertainty, traceable to a national standard ±5%, NIST-traceable (SQ-500, LI-190R)
Drift A yearly figure and a recalibration interval Under 2% a year (SQ-500, LI-190R)
Range and linearity Covers full sun (2,000 µmol/m²/s in Virginia Tech’s example) SQ-500: 0 to 4,000 µmol/m²/s, non-linearity under 1%
Temperature response A small per-degree figure for warm grow spaces SQ-500: −0.11% per °C; LI-190R: ±0.15% per °C maximum
Sensor area Point sensor for spot checks, line sensor to average a bench LI-191R: 1 m by 12.7 mm, ±10% calibration
Output A display for spot checks, logger output for DLI SQ-500: 0 to 40 mV analog, read by a separate meter or logger

Sources

  1. Owner's Manual: Quantum Sensor, Model SQ-500Apogee Instruments
  2. LI-190R and LI-191R Quantum Sensor | SpecificationsLI-COR Biosciences
  3. Accurate PAR Measurements: Spectral and Directional Errors of Seven Quantum SensorsSmith and Blonquist (Apogee Instruments), ASHS Annual Conference abstract, 2018
  4. Accuracy of Quantum Sensors Measuring Yield Photon Flux and Photosynthetic Photon FluxBarnes et al., HortScience 28(12):1197-1200 (1993)
  5. Guidelines for measuring and reporting environmental parameters for experiments in greenhousesBoth et al., Plant Methods 11:43 (2015)
  6. Calculating and Using Daily Light Integral (DLI): An Introductory GuideVirginia Cooperative Extension (Virginia Tech)

General information, not professional advice for a specific plant or crop. Spot something wrong? Email info@terrathink.io.

Keep reading

All field notes

Join the waitlist

New field notes by email, and first word when the hardware goes live.

By joining, you agree to get email updates from Terrathink. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy