Field NotesComparisonsNo. 16

How to choose a pH and EC meter for plants: pens, combo meters and soil probes

The extra decimal on the display isn’t accuracy, and the pH electrode wears out long before the meter. Here is what to read on a spec sheet and what extension specialists say growers need.

A gloved hand holds a meter whose probes sit in a beaker of soil and water

The short answer For most growers, a pen or handheld meter that reads both pH and EC is enough, if it has automatic temperature compensation, two-point pH calibration and a replaceable pH electrode. Judge it by its accuracy figure, not the decimals on the display, and budget for buffers, storage solution and a new pH electrode every year or two.

An EC and pH meter is two sensors in one purchase, and they age differently. The pH sensor is a glass electrode that must stay wet, needs regular calibration and typically lasts a year or two. Choosing well mostly comes down to how a meter handles that part.

This note covers hardware. For what the readings mean, units, ppm scales and root-zone sampling, see EC and pH for plants.

Pens, handheld meters and soil probes

Pens (pocket testers) put meter and sensor in one stick that you dip into a sample, such as pot runoff or a nutrient reservoir. Hanna’s HI98131 GroLine, a combination pH and EC pen, is one example.

Handheld meters with separate probes keep the electronics in one body and the sensors on cables. The Bluelab Combo Meter has a conductivity and temperature probe and a pH probe on 2 m (6.6 ft) cables. The pH probe plugs in with a BNC connector and can be replaced on its own. Bluelab’s warranty hints at which part wears: a five-year limited warranty on the meter, six months on the pH probe.

Combo or separate is a choice within either form. Purdue Extension says monitoring substrate pH and EC “requires a metering device that will measure both.” A combo is one tool to carry and calibrate, but its pH electrode wears out long before the electronics, so make sure it’s replaceable. Both examples here qualify.

Direct soil or substrate probes skip the sample. Hanna’s HI98331 Soil Test, a pocket tester “specifically designed to directly measure soil conductivity (EC),” has a fixed 114 mm (4.5 in) stainless steel probe. Hanna says to check that the soil is moist and to make a hole with a ruler or auger first, which “keeps the testing depth consistent.” Bluelab also sells a soil pH probe for its Combo Meter.

Extension specialists are wary. Purdue doesn’t recommend sticking a sensor into the substrate unless moisture is highly consistent and you measure on the same day each week as part of a routine program. UMass Extension, writing about low-priced meters sold this way, says the approach “has no basis in scientific soil testing.” Purdue’s interpretation ranges are written for PourThru, saturated media extract (SME) and 1:2 samples, so a direct reading can’t be checked against them. As the plant sensor comparison notes, EC in the soil and EC of the liquid that drains out are different numbers.

What extension specialists recommend

  • Affordable is fine. Purdue: “Portable, affordable units are available and very accurate.” UMass says inexpensive pens “can be used in the greenhouse for assessing pH and soluble salts” and work on the same basic principles as pricier meters. Its undated pen fact sheet priced single pH or EC pens at $50 to $60.
  • Automatic features help. Purdue: “Units that feature automatic calibration and temperature compensation are desirable.”
  • It must calibrate. UMass: a meter with no means of calibration “is probably not going to give good results.”

The specs that matter

Specs as each maker’s page gives them:

Spec Hanna HI98131 GroLine (pen) Bluelab Combo Meter (handheld) Hanna HI98331 Soil Test (soil probe)
pH range, display step, accuracy 0.00 to 14.00, 0.01, ±0.1 0.0 to 14.0, 0.1, ±0.1 at 25 °C No pH
EC range 0.00 to 6.00 mS/cm 0.0 to 9.9 EC 0.00 to 4.00 mS/cm
EC display step, accuracy 0.01 mS/cm, ±2% F.S. 0.1, ±0.1 0.01 mS/cm; ±0.05 mS/cm to 2.00, ±0.30 above
Temperature compensation Automatic; EC at 1.9% per °C Not in the spec table Automatic; 2% per °C
ppm scales 500 or 700 500 (TDS) or 700 None listed
Water resistance IP65, not for full submersion Not stated Not stated
Calibration pH: one or two points (4.01, 7.01, 10.01); EC: not stated pH: two points, 30-day reminder; EC: factory-calibrated EC: one point, 1413 µS/cm
Sensor Replaceable pH electrode Replaceable pH probe Fixed steel probe

Range. The EC scale should top out above what you’ll measure. Purdue rates PourThru readings of 6.6 to 7.8 mS/cm as very high and above 7.8 as extreme, both beyond the HI98131, which stops at 6.00.

Resolution vs. accuracy. Resolution is the smallest step the display shows; accuracy is how far that number may be from the truth. The HI98131 shows pH to 0.01 but is rated ±0.1, so a reading of 6.05 could be anywhere from 5.95 to 6.15. The Bluelab shows 0.1 with the same ±0.1. The extra digit isn’t extra accuracy.

EC accuracy is often a percentage of full scale (F.S.), the top of the range, not of your reading:

error = (F.S. % ÷ 100) × range maximum

where error is the plus-or-minus band in mS/cm, F.S. % is the rated percentage and range maximum is the top of the EC scale. Example: ±2% F.S. on the HI98131’s 6.00 mS/cm scale is ±0.12 mS/cm anywhere on it. At a reading of 1.20, that’s 1.08 to 1.32, or ±10%.

Temperature compensation. Readings shift with temperature (the EC and pH note explains how much for EC), so look for automatic temperature compensation (ATC) on both pH and EC. The temperature coefficient, β, is set at 1.9% per °C on the HI98131 and fixed at 2% per °C on the HI98331. None of the three pages states the reference temperature readings are corrected to; check the manual.

ppm scales. Both combo examples show ppm on the 500 or 700 scale. If a feeding chart uses another scale, or names none, read EC and use the EC to ppm converter.

Water resistance. Read the rating, not the name. Hanna’s page title calls the HI98131 waterproof, but it’s rated IP65: it “can withstand being dropped accidentally into a liquid” and is “not designed for full submersion.”

pH electrode care and lifespan

Hanna says pH electrodes typically last 1 to 2 years with proper care at room temperature (25 °C), and as a rule of thumb, a general-purpose electrode’s life halves for every 25 °C increase. Its electrodes carry a six-month warranty, like Bluelab’s pH probe. Hence the replaceable electrode: Hanna sells the HI98131’s as a spare (HI-73127), and Bluelab’s probe unplugs.

To keep one working (Hanna, unless noted):

  • Keep the glass wet in storage solution. Bluelab ships its meter with KCl (potassium chloride) storage solution and a probe cap that holds it.
  • Never store it in purified water. Hanna says deionized water has an osmotic effect on the electrode’s internal reference solution and shortens its life. A gel-filled electrode stored that way must be replaced.
  • Don’t let it dry out. It can be rehydrated in storage solution, “however, even with rehydration, response and accuracy can be compromised.”
  • Don’t wipe the bulb. Wiping can strip the delicate hydrated glass layer, causing “irreparable damage.”
  • Keep it clean. A dirty electrode is the most common cause of inaccurate readings. Clean and rinse it the way its manual says.
  • Store it indoors. Purdue: keep meters and solutions in a low-humidity room at room temperature, never in the greenhouse or outside.

Calibration: pH buffers and EC standards

UMass puts it plainly: “Calibration is a must.” You place the probe in a solution of known value, wait for a stable reading, set the display to match, and discard the used solution.

One point or two. UMass describes calibrating with pH 7 buffer alone, or at two points with pH 4 and 7. The HI98131 does one or two points with 4.01, 7.01 and 10.01 buffers; Bluelab’s meter uses two and ships with pH 7.0 and 4.0 sachets.

Which buffers. Purdue says to calibrate to the pH range you’re testing; for peat or bark, that may mean calibrating at 4.0. Its range for ready nutrient availability, pH 5.4 to 6.2, sits between 4 and 7, so those two buffers suit most plant samples. Save pH 10 for samples above 7.

How often. UMass says it depends on the meter and how often you use it; calibrate at the start of every testing session until you learn how much readings drift between sessions. Bluelab’s meter prompts you after 30 days.

EC standards. The value depends on the meter. The HI98331 calibrates at one point with a 1413 µS/cm (1.41 mS/cm) standard. Bluelab’s conductivity probe is factory-calibrated and, Bluelab says, needs no further calibration; a reading in a standard solution is still a quick way to confirm it. The HI98131 page doesn’t name its EC standard, so check the manual before buying solution. Purdue and UMass both treat an EC standard as part of the kit.

A buying checklist

  • Reads both pH and EC.
  • EC range above your highest expected reading.
  • An accuracy figure in real units, not just the display step.
  • ATC on pH and EC, with β and reference temperature in the manual.
  • EC in mS/cm, and a ppm scale you can name.
  • Two-point pH calibration with 4 and 7 buffers, and a stated EC standard (or a factory-calibrated EC probe you can check against one).
  • A replaceable pH electrode, with spares sold.
  • A water rating that fits your use. Hanna’s IP65 pen is rated for an accidental drop, not submersion.
  • Running costs: buffers, EC standard, storage solution, and a new pH electrode every year or two.

Sources

  1. HO-237: pH and Electrical Conductivity Measurements in Soilless SubstratesPurdue University Extension, Horticulture and Landscape Architecture (Camberato, Lopez and Mickelbart)
  2. How to Use pH and EC "Pens" to Monitor Greenhouse Crop NutritionUMass Extension, Greenhouse Crops and Floriculture (Cox)
  3. HI-98131 GroLine Hydroponic Waterproof Pocket pH/EC/TDS/Temperature TesterHanna Instruments UK
  4. Bluelab Combo Meter | pH & EC Meter for HydroponicsBluelab USA
  5. Soil Test Direct Soil Conductivity Tester - HI98331Hanna Instruments
  6. How long will my pH electrode last?Hanna Instruments Knowledge Base

General information, not professional advice for a specific plant or crop. Spot something wrong? Email info@terrathink.io.

Keep reading

All field notes

Join the waitlist

New field notes by email, and first word when the hardware goes live.

By joining, you agree to get email updates from Terrathink. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy