Field NotesClassroomNo. 19

How to measure the rate of photosynthesis in class: the floating leaf disk lab and two more

Leaf disks that sink, then rise as they make oxygen, turn photosynthesis into a count students can graph. Here is the full method, two other ways to measure it, and how to read the numbers.

A student in safety glasses and a lab coat cuts a piece of aloe leaf at a white lab bench

The short answer Pull the air out of small leaf disks with a syringe so they sink in weak baking soda solution, set them under a bright light, and count how many float each minute. The time for half to float (ET50) gives a rate, 1/ET50, to graph against light or baking soda. Counting pondweed bubbles and logging carbon dioxide in a sealed jar are two other options.

These three methods turn a leaf’s invisible oxygen into numbers. To plan a unit around them, see how to build a plant science lesson plan.

Three ways to measure photosynthesis

Method Students record Main equipment Time
Floating leaf disks Disks floating each minute Needle-free syringes, hole punch, baking soda, dish soap, lamp One 45-minute period to learn, about two for student-designed tests (College Board)
Pondweed bubbles Bubbles per minute, or gas collected Elodea, clear tube, lamp, ruler One period
Sealed jar Carbon dioxide (ppm), light then dark CO2 or oxygen sensor, clear jar; bromothymol blue as the low-tech version One period; overnight for the indicator

The floating leaf disk lab, step by step

Materials (College Board): baking soda, liquid dish soap, two plastic syringes without needles (10 mL or larger), fresh leaves (ivy and spinach work well), a hole punch, two clear plastic cups, a timer, a strong light, goggles, aprons and gloves.

  1. Make the solutions. Use 300 mL of 0.2% bicarbonate solution, the carbon dioxide source, per experiment. That’s 2 g of baking soda per liter, so mix a liter and share it. For dilute soap, stir about 5 mL of dish soap into 250 mL of water.
  2. Fill the cups. Pour bicarbonate solution about 3 cm deep in one cup and plain water in the other, the control. Add one drop of dilute soap to each; it’s a wetting agent for the leaf’s water-repellent surface. Avoid suds; dilute a foamy cup with more of its own liquid.
  3. Punch the disks. Cut 10 or more uniform disks per cup, avoiding major veins.
  4. Sink them. Pull the plunger from a syringe, drop in 10 disks, and push the plunger back until less than 10% air remains. Draw in a little bicarbonate solution (soapy water for the control syringe), tap to suspend the disks and push out the air. Cap the tip with a finger, pull back the plunger, and hold the vacuum about 10 seconds while swirling. Release, and the disks sink. Repeat two or three times if needed; more than three vacuums can damage the disks.
  5. Count. Pour each syringe into its cup, set both under the light together and start the timer. At the end of each minute, record the floating disks in each cup, then swirl to free any stuck to the side. Continue until every disk in the bicarbonate cup floats.

What to change: light, color and baking soda

Change one thing per run and keep the plain-water control. College Board also suggests plant type, leaf age, and shade vs. sun leaves.

  • Light intensity. Set cups at, say, 10, 20 and 40 cm from one lamp. Practical Biology notes intensity is proportional to 1/distance², so doubling the distance leaves roughly a quarter of the light. Measure at each cup anyway; College Board says a PAR meter “will greatly facilitate experimental design.” The PPFD, lux and DLI calculator converts lux readings.
  • Light color. Put colored cellophane between lamp and cup. OpenStax notes chlorophyll a absorbs blue and red but not green, so students can predict green will be slowest, then test it. Practical Biology warns that filters cut intensity unevenly by color, so measure light through each one.
  • Baking soda. Try 0.1%, 0.2% and 0.4% (1, 2 and 4 g per liter) beside the plain-water cup.
  • Light, then dark. Once disks float, slide a box over the cup and keep counting. Respiration consumes the oxygen in the leaf’s air spaces, “causing the disks to sink again” (College Board). In its example, sinking was slower than floating.

Why the disks float

Leaves float because they hold gas. The vacuum draws air out of the spongy mesophyll (inner leaf tissue) and solution refills the space, so the disk sinks (College Board).

Light starts the light-dependent reactions, which OpenStax says convert light energy into chemical energy, stored in ATP and NADPH. To keep them running, water is split, and the byproduct oxygen leaves the cells, collecting in a sunken disk’s air spaces until it rises. That energy then powers the Calvin cycle, which builds sugar from carbon the bicarbonate supplies, so disks in plain water should lag behind.

The leaf also respires, using oxygen, so College Board treats float time as a measure of the net rate of photosynthesis. A shorter ET50 means a faster rate, hence graphing 1/ET50.

NGSS link. In middle school this supports MS-LS1-6: “Construct a scientific explanation based on evidence for the role of photosynthesis in the cycling of matter and flow of energy into and out of organisms.” In high school it supports HS-LS1-5: “Use a model to illustrate how photosynthesis transforms light energy into stored chemical energy.” Neither assesses biochemical steps, so treat ATP and NADPH as enrichment and keep explanations on inputs, outputs and energy.

Count bubbles from pondweed

Practical Biology’s version:

  • Cut 10 cm lengths of Elodea (some find Cabomba bubbles more), weigh one end down with a paper clip and stand it in a clear tube of water in a darkened room, a measured distance from the lamp.
  • After each change, wait 2 minutes, then count bubbles from the cut end for 1 minute. Repeat twice and take the mean.
  • No bubbles? Cutting 2 to 3 mm off the end sometimes starts them.
  • For better numbers, collect the gas: cut the graduated part from a plastic dropper pipette, fill it with water, plug the small end, invert it over the cut stem and read the volume collected in a fixed time.

Bubble counts assume every bubble is oxygen, all are the same size, and oxygen output tracks photosynthesis. Collecting gas removes the size problem. Lamps can heat the water (LEDs produce less heat), so log its temperature.

Track carbon dioxide in a sealed jar

College Board also suggests dissolved oxygen or carbon dioxide sensors; measuring respiration in the same system, it adds, lets you estimate gross production.

A suggested starting setup: fresh spinach leaves and the sensor in a sealed, clear 1-liter jar under the lamp. Try logging every 30 seconds for 10 to 15 minutes lit, then 10 to 15 minutes under a box.

  • Light: carbon dioxide should fall, since photosynthesis turns carbon dioxide and water into sugar (NGSS).
  • Dark: it should rise, since respiration produces carbon dioxide as a byproduct (CIRES at CU Boulder).
  • Oxygen sensor: the mirror image.

Each segment’s slope, in ppm per minute, is the rate. High schoolers can add the dark rise rate to the light fall rate for a rough gross rate, assuming respiration holds steady.

Low-tech version. CIRES uses bromothymol blue (BTB), which turns from blue (no carbon dioxide) to green (low) to yellow (high) because carbon dioxide forms weak carbonic acid. Bubble breath gently through a straw into the BTB until yellow, then fill four test tubes half full. Add an Elodea sprig to two, cap all four, and wrap one plain and one plant tube in foil. Set them in a well-lit spot and check the next day; in CIRES’s sample results only the lit Elodea tube turned blue. For a number, score each tube against a printed color strip at set times.

Graph the results

  • Leaf disks: disks floating (y) against minutes (x), one line per cup. ET50 is where a line crosses half the disks; College Board uses the median rather than the mean. Then plot 1/ET50 against light, distance or baking soda.
  • Example, made-up numbers: 4 of 10 disks float at minute 6 and 6 at minute 7, so ET50 is about 6.5 minutes.

rate = 1 ÷ ET50

where rate is per minute and ET50 is in minutes. Here 1 ÷ 6.5 ≈ 0.15 per minute. A cup with an ET50 of 13 minutes scores 1 ÷ 13 ≈ 0.077, half the rate.

  • Pondweed: the factor on the x-axis, bubbles per minute on the y-axis (Practical Biology).
  • Sealed jar: carbon dioxide (ppm) against time, dark periods shaded, slopes labeled.
  • Every graph: units and instrument on the axes. More sensor setups are in classroom plant experiments with sensors.

Troubleshooting and safety

  • Disks won’t sink. Usually too little soap, says College Board: add a few more drops and replace the liquid in the syringe. Punch fresh disks rather than exceed three vacuums.
  • Disks never float. “A strong light source is necessary” (College Board). Move the lamp closer, adding a heat filter.
  • Heat. A bulb too close warms the water and skews results (College Board). Use LEDs or a water heat filter (a clear container of water between lamp and cups), and record water temperature at the start and end.

Safety:

  • Goggles for every method. College Board requires goggles, aprons and gloves, citing exposed bulbs that can shatter; CIRES requires goggles and aprons for BTB.
  • Lamps and water. Keep solutions away from cords and power strips, never drip water on hot bulbs (shatter hazard), and don’t lean on lamps (burns).
  • Needle-free syringes only.
  • BTB. Warn students not to inhale it, and give each their own straw; CIRES puts a cotton ball in the tube mouth to stop spills. Dispose of BTB as the manufacturer suggests.
  • No boiling, no alcohol. Skip any add-on leaf test that calls for either.
  • Allergies and hygiene. Ask about plant and latex allergies; offer nitrile gloves. Pond water carries a slight infection risk (Practical Biology): cover cuts and wash hands.
  • Disposal. Baking soda and soap solutions can go down the sink. Bag leftover pondweed for the trash; never release aquarium or pond plants outdoors.

Sources

  1. Investigation 5: PhotosynthesisCollege Board (AP Biology lab manual)
  2. Investigating factors affecting the rate of photosynthesisPractical Biology, Royal Society of Biology
  3. Photosynthesis, Respiration, and the Short-Term Carbon Cycle (Teacher Guide, Middle School)CIRES Education & Outreach, University of Colorado Boulder
  4. 5.2 The Light-Dependent Reactions of PhotosynthesisOpenStax, Concepts of Biology
  5. MS-LS1 From Molecules to Organisms: Structures and ProcessesNext Generation Science Standards
  6. HS-LS1 From Molecules to Organisms: Structures and ProcessesNext Generation Science Standards

General information, not professional advice for a specific plant or crop. Spot something wrong? Email info@terrathink.io.

Keep reading

All field notes

Join the waitlist

New field notes by email, and first word when the hardware goes live.

By joining, you agree to get email updates from Terrathink. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy policy